Elon, Tesla & the 'S' in ESG – Fidelity International

Update your operating system
Your computer’s operating system is out of date. To get the best experience of our website and enhanced security, please update your operating system
Home    Investing ideas    Sustainable & ESG investing
Published 8 June 2022
Investment writer

Important information: The value of investments and the income from them, can go down as well as up, so you may get back less than you invest.
ELON Musk labelled Tesla’s ejection from the S&P 500 ESG index as “a clear case of wacktivism”, but he may be missing the growing importance of the ‘social’ factor in Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) investing. The electric car maker’s exit from the widely-followed index came after the California Department of Fair Employment and Housing filed a lawsuit over racial harassment and discrimination at its manufacturing plant in Fremont1.
S&P also mentioned safety concerns with crashes linked to Tesla’s autopilot vehicles.
Hortense Bioy, director, sustainability research at Morningstar says: “Investors should be aware that E and S don’t always align. This is what Tesla partly demonstrates. You can offer some of the best and most innovative environmentally friendly products but the way you operate your business, including the way you treat your employees or, as well as the safety of your products may be short of the mark.”
Tesla isn’t the only company to fall foul of the ‘s’ factor. Clothing group Boohoo, a previous ESG favourite, got into trouble over pay and conditions at some of its suppliers in Leicester2. In 2020, the UK government ‘named and shamed’ 139 firms, including Tesco, Costco and Superdrug for failing to pay workers the minimum wage3, while groups such as Ocado have faced shareholder rebellions over management pay. The condemnation of P&O Ferries’ sacking of 800 employees shows a growing focus on workers’ rights.
Social issues have been gaining prominence for investors more recently. These include companies’ treatment of staff, diversity, health and safety record, and supply chain standards. Bioy says the pandemic highlighted and accelerated inequalities. Companies had to prioritise the safety of their workers and customers. And have been forced into tough decisions. Where they have made those decisions badly, it has had a meaningful impact on their profitability.
There is a growing weight of evidence from academic studies highlighting the strong relationship between social performance and long-term financial performance. A recent study from Federated Hermes showed a tangible link between companies with a better record on social factors and share price performance4.
Regulators are also starting to pay more attention to social issues. The European Union is developing a ‘social taxonomy’, with the UK likely to follow suit. The UK also has mandatory gender pay gap reporting. These initiatives may help define social goals and help companies develop metrics to report on them. They should also address a perennial gripe with the social factor – that it is hard to measure. While carbon emissions are relatively easy to track, the same cannot be said for the way a company treats its staff.
Many fund groups have started to call for a social transition – a fundamental change to the way companies look at profit.
All this should be a win-win for investors – as well as building for a fairer society, it’s also becoming increasingly clear that socially orientated companies make for good investments.
On the one hand, such companies avoid scandals and the subsequent selloffs that come with shoddy practices. On the other, they tend to be building for a long-term, sustainable future. They’re keeping up with market trends and demands, and typically can point to strong management guiding their decision-making. In other words, they’re the sort of companies that most of us look to invest in.
Moreover, funds that take their companies’ social responsibilities seriously are also likely to demonstrate the same sort of risk analysis and screening processes that we’d expect from any competent management team.
S is becoming an increasingly important factor in investors’ decision-making. Not only is that good for society – it’s good too for returns.
1 CBS News, February 2022
2 Guardian, September 2020
3 Business Live, December 2020
4 Insitutional Asset Manager, January 2021
Important information: Investors should note that the views expressed may no longer be current and may have already been acted upon. Overseas investments will be affected by movements in currency exchange rates. Reference to specific securities should not be construed as a recommendation to buy or sell these securities and is included for the purposes of illustration only. The Investment Manager’s focus on securities of companies which maintain strong environmental, social and governance (“ESG”) credentials may result in a return that at times compares unfavourably to similar products without such focus. No representation nor warranty is made with respect to the fairness, accuracy or completeness of such credentials. The status of a security’s ESG credentials can change over time This information is not a personal recommendation for any particular investment. If you are unsure about the suitability of an investment you should speak to one of Fidelity’s advisers or an authorised financial adviser of your choice.
Share this article
Get daily views, insights and content to keep your finger on the pulse.
Invest in what you know
Becks Nunn
Fidelity International
09 June 2022
The US stock market offers some unique opportunities
Emma-Lou Montgomery
Fidelity International
09 June 2022
This week, what is the lasting appeal of gold – and why does it still hold th…
Ed Monk
Fidelity International
09 June 2022
Learn more about sustainable investing and use our Sustainable Investment Finder to discover options that focus on the issues you care about.
Search through the thousands of investments we offer with our powerful investment finder tool.
Our team of advisers can help you achieve your investment goals, whether those relate to one-off events or more complex needs with ongoing support.
Please remember that past performance is not necessarily a guide to future performance, the performance of investments is not guaranteed, and the value of your investments can go down as well as up, so you may get back less than you invest. When investments have particular tax features, these will depend on your personal circumstances and tax rules may change in the future. This website does not contain any personal recommendations for a particular course of action, service or product. You should regularly review your investment objectives and choices and, if you are unsure whether an investment is suitable for you, you should contact an authorised financial adviser. Before opening an account, please read the ‘Doing Business with Fidelity’ document which incorporates our client terms. Prior to investing into a fund, please read the relevant key information document which contains important information about the fund.

This website is issued by Financial Administration Services Limited, which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) (FCA Register number 122169) and registered in England and Wales under company number 1629709 whose registered address is Beech Gate, Millfield Lane, Lower Kingswood, Tadworth, Surrey, KT20 6RP.
© FIL Limited 2022

Fidelity uses cookies to provide you with the best possible online experience. If you continue without changing your settings, we’ll assume that you are happy to receive all cookies on our site. However, you can change the cookie settings and view our cookie policy at any time.


Posted in Blog
Write a comment
Contact Us
Contact Us